Jigsaw piece puzzle

Issue: Definition, Example and Related Terms

What is an Issue ?

An issue in the context of contracts and legal proceedings refers to a point or matter that is contested or in dispute between parties. It is a particular topic or aspect of the agreement that the parties do not agree on, and which must be resolved, either through negotiation, mediation, arbitration, or litigation.

For example, in a contractual dispute between a supplier and a buyer, one issue may be whether the goods delivered meet the quality standards specified in the contract. The supplier might believe that the goods meet the required standards, while the buyer contests this point, arguing that they do not.

Identifying the issues in a contractual dispute is a crucial step in the resolution process. It helps the parties understand what specific points need to be addressed and resolved. This can make the negotiation or legal process more efficient, as it allows the parties to focus on the specific areas of disagreement.

Issues can be both factual and legal. Factual issues concern the actual events or circumstances in a case, such as whether a delivery was made on time. Legal issues, on the other hand, involve the interpretation of the law or contract terms, such as how a particular clause should be interpreted.

Effective issue identification and framing are essential skills for contract managers and legal professionals. It helps them structure their arguments, gather relevant evidence, and develop a strategy for resolving the dispute. Properly identifying the issues can also facilitate settlement discussions by narrowing the focus to the key points of contention.

Example(s)

  • Scenario Description
    A software company and a client are in a contract dispute over deliverables. One issue in the dispute could be whether the software delivered meets the specifications outlined in the contract. The software company argues that it does, while the client believes certain features are missing.
    A construction firm and a property owner are in a legal dispute over project delays. One key issue might be determining whether the delays were caused by the construction firm’s mismanagement or by unforeseen weather conditions, as each party holds the other responsible.
    A service provider and a customer are disputing over payment terms. A central issue could be the interpretation of the payment clause in their contract. The service provider believes the payment is due upon completion, while the customer interprets it as due 30 days post-completion.

Related terms